Case Study

Replacing a Physical Binder with a Living System

Dick's Sporting Goods employees were using outdated physical binders to make real-time security tagging decisions. I designed a SaaS solution — alone, end to end — that replaced them entirely.

Role Lead UX Designer (Sole Designer)
Domain SaaS · Enterprise Mobile · Retail Operations
Platform Mobile App (TC52 + phone) + Corporate Web Portal
Timeline 3 Months, Discovery through Delivery
1
Designer on the Entire Project
3 mo
Discovery to Delivery
0
Physical Binders Remaining
4
Stakeholder Groups Served

The Problem

A Binder Can't Get a Software Update

Store employees at Dick's Sporting Goods determined which security tag to use — and where to place it — by flipping through a physical binder called the MES (Merchandise Exposure Standards). When corporate updated the standards, those updates traveled slowly through store managers, printed on paper, inserted into binders that may or may not have been current.

The results were predictable: incorrect tagging, product damage, theft from under-tagged items, customer frustration from over-tagged ones, and store employees spending time hunting for information instead of serving customers.

The system wasn't broken. It was never designed in the first place.

Stakeholders

Four Groups. One Solution.

Before designing anything, I mapped the full stakeholder ecosystem. Each group had a different relationship with the problem.

🧑‍🏪
Store Employees
Primary users. Needed instant, accurate tag guidance at the point of task — not a binder in a back room.
🏢
Corporate Management
Needed to push standard updates to all locations simultaneously, without relying on a chain of managers to communicate changes.
💻
IT Department
Inherited a repurposed HR flashcard app that couldn't handle image databases or search. Needed a real solution they could actually maintain.
🛍️
Customers
Experienced the downstream effects: damaged products, missing inventory, slow checkout when tags interfered with purchase.

Research

I Talked to Everyone

I conducted surveys across all four stakeholder groups — corporate employees, store managers, floor staff, and customers — in sequence. Each layer revealed a new dimension of the same problem. Corporate didn't know how broken the binder system was at the store level. Store managers didn't realize how much time employees spent searching. Employees didn't know updates had even been issued.

Workflow Analysis
Mapped the existing 4-step MES process: LP identifies candidates → presents to management → creates standards → store teammates reference app. Found critical communication gaps at every handoff.
Technology Assessment
Evaluated device compatibility, battery life, WiFi reliability, ergonomics, and multitasking feasibility across the TC52 scanner and employee phones. Identified 13 specific technical constraints that shaped design decisions.

Design Decisions

Simple by Necessity. Intentional by Design.

The TC52 device had real technical constraints: limited processing power, inconsistent WiFi, and employees who needed to simultaneously hold merchandise, a security tag, and a device. Every design decision was shaped by these realities.

1
Minimalist interface
Kept the app interface stripped to essentials. Fast load times, no crashes, immediate access to tagging guidance after scanning a barcode.
2
Product scan feature
Employees scan a product barcode and instantly receive the correct tag type, placement diagram, and any current standards — no searching, no binder.
3
Corporate portal
Designed a separate web-based admin tool for corporate employees to push updated standards, product images, and placement diagrams to all stores simultaneously — eliminating the manager middleman.

Branding

From LockMES to Protect It

I developed the initial brand identity — "LockMES" — combining a lock icon, a scanner illustration, and a trust-building blue palette. After stakeholder feedback indicated a preference for a simpler, more authoritative feel, I redesigned the brand entirely.

The final identity — "Protect It" — used black as its dominant color with a key motif, projecting security and control. I ensured the name was distinctive enough to be found easily among the many apps on employee devices.

Outcomes

A Binder That Never Goes Out of Date

The "Protect It" SaaS solution replaced the physical MES binder system entirely. Store employees could scan a product and receive accurate, current tagging guidance in seconds. Corporate could push updates to every store simultaneously. The manager bottleneck was eliminated.

↑ Tagging Efficiency
Significant reduction in time spent determining correct tags and placement. Employees no longer needed to seek manager approval before completing MES tasks.
📦
↓ Product Damage
Lower incidence of damage from incorrect tag placement, improving product integrity and reducing shrink.
🔄
↑ Communication Speed
Corporate-to-store standards updates became instant, eliminating the slow, inconsistent manual distribution process.
High Satisfaction
Employees reported finding the system intuitive and helpful in daily tasks — a meaningful shift from the frustration of the binder system.

What I Learned

Enterprise UX Is a Systems Problem

This project taught me that enterprise UX isn't just about the interface — it's about the entire system of people, processes, and tools that the interface sits inside.

Designing the employee-facing app was only half the work. The corporate portal, the update workflow, the device constraints, the stakeholder alignment — all of it was the design. The binder wasn't a bad tool. It was a symptom of a system that had never been intentionally designed. That's what I replaced.

"Enterprise UX isn't about making a better screen. It's about understanding every person, process, and handoff that the screen sits inside — and designing for all of them at once."

— Stephanie Gross, Lead UX Designer